After a romantic dinner at the Addams' favorite bistro, Fester and Debbie walk in the graveyard behind the mansion. Debbie then lies to Fester by saying she is a virgin and wishes she had a man for herself. Fester, believing she really loves him, becomes engaged to her. Debbie marries Fester, then promptly tries to kill him on their Hawaiian honeymoon by electrocuting him in the jacuzzi; however, Fester is an Addams (and hence practically indestructible as he is practically indulged to death and suffering) and he mistakes her murderous actions for ordinary affection. At her wits' end, Debbie denies him sex until he promises never to see his family again; in anguish, he agrees. The newlyweds couple then move to a garish McMansion in the suburbs, Debbie driving them there in her Lincoln Town Car. Several weeks later, Gomez, Morticia, Granny, and Lurch come to the mansion in hopes to be able to visit Fester. They fail to do so as Debbie threatens to lock them up if they try to visit again. After the Addamses fail to get the police to arrest Debbie, Debbie renews her passport, telling the clerk that she will be traveling alone because "she'll be a widow."
With Fester gone, brother Gomez goes into a depression and Pubert becomes "possessed," causing him to become blonde, rosy and cheerful. Meanwhile, at Camp Chippewa, Wednesday and Pugsley don't fit in with the rest of the wealthy campers. During the lifesaving activity, Wednesday intentionally lets her partner drown in the lake. At night, during the ghost story, when it is Wednesday's turn to continue the story, she tells of the ghost undoing all of the camper's nose jobs overnight, which causes her fellow campers to scream in terror. The Addams children try to escape at night when they receive word of Uncle Fester's marriage to Debbie, but are caught by the other campers. The camp's golden girl Amanda Buckman (played by Mercedes McNab), and the rest of the campers suggest that the Addams kids be punished for their escape attempt, but the camp counselors Gary and Becky, would prefer to inspire them by singing Kumbaya which makes Wednesday and Pugsley cringe. Meanwhile, Wednesday encounters a soul mate (of sorts) in the person of Joel Glicker, an introverted Jewish boy plagued by allergies. He confirms her suspicions that Debbie is the "Black Widow" and Fester is her next target.
Meanwhile, at Fester and Debbie's house, Debbie has indeed come up with a new plan to kill Fester for his fortune. For their "3 week anniversary", she wraps up a time bomb in a gift box and tells Fester not to open it until she comes back with some champagne. Thing is seen watching through the window as Debbie says "she'll be right back" even though she is seen carrying two suitcases out to her car. Fester, excited about everything, returns to the kitchen to finish cooking their dinner with the time bomb ticking away on the dining room table.
Back at Camp Chippewa, for the end of the summer,the camp is about to put on a play about "The First Thanksgiving" with the snobbish rich kids cast as the pilgrims with Amanda as Sarah Miller, the leading pilgrim, and the social outcasts cast as the Chippewa natives with Wednesday as Pocahantas. When Wednesday, Pugsley and Joel refuse to act in the play, all three outcasts are locked in the "Harmony Hut" and forced to watch movies and TV shows ranging from Bambi to Lassie Come Home to The Little Mermaid to The Sound of Music to The Brady Bunch to Annie. When the three come out, they pretend that they have changed from gloomy to cheerful. During the performance, however, Wednesday breaks out of her character and rants about how the American colonists would exploit the Native Americans in the future and leads the other outcasts in destroying the set, tying up Amanda and placing an apple in her mouth as a gag. Afterwards the Addams siblings flee the camp for home.

.
Meanwhile, when Debbie fails to kill Fester by blowing up the house, she snarls, "I want you dead, and I want your money!" He flees with Thing's help, going on a high-speed pursuit through the suburban streets in Debbie's Lincoln Town Car. However, Debbie chases them to the Addams mansion in her second car, Mercedes-Benz SL-Class. Gomez is lying in bed dying when Fester arrives to tell them how he is in mysery, when Gomez tells Fester that he belongs to Debbie, Fester boasts "I'M AN ADDAMS!!!". With that said, Gomez is instantly cured, and the baby is back to it's dark gloomy self. Pugsley and Wednesday arrive afterwards, at first unhappy because they were made to sing while at camp, but are glad to be back none the less. But then an angry Debbie bursts into the room with one intention: Kill the Addamses and take the money. She straps everyone except Pubert to electric chairs and uses slides to tell her story about how she killed her parents as a child on her 10th birthday because they didn't buy her the Barbie doll that she wanted. The Addams Family watches, getting into Debbie's life story as she explains that she killed her first husband, a heart surgeon, with an axe because he was too busy to attend dinner with her. Also, she went on to kill her second husband, a senator, by running over him with her car because he wouldn't buy her a new Mercedes-Benz. Finally, she ends her show on a slide of Fester, him being the only husband unsuccessfully killed. Then she accuses the Addamses of not truly "loving her". Fester begs Debbie to just kill him and take his fortune but spare the others, but Debbie (wanting the whole Addams fortune as opposed to just Fester's portion) has already decided that everyone must go. But Pubert short-circuits the wiring just as she throws the switch; instead of killing the Addamses, she electrocutes herself, her body burns and leaves only her shoes and credit cards in a pile of ashes.
In the epilogue, Gomez and Morticia throw a birthday party for Pubert. Among the guests is a potential new love for Fester, a bald, grotesque nanny named Dementia who works for Itt and Margaret Addams (who have an Itt Jr. named "What"). Joel, dressed like Gomez, also attends and sneaks off to the graveyard with Wednesday, where they talk briefly about Debbie. Remarking that Debbie's methods were "sloppy," Wednesday says that if sheeCarrie); Wednesday looks on, satisfied with Joel's screams.
