|
Rating:  -
I've been a fan of Denny O'Neil's for years and was quite surprised that he did the novelization of the movie,"The Dark Knight". In my opinion, despite what other reviewers are saying, I think he did a wonderful job writing it. He certainly fleshed out the characters alot more to where I understand certain things from the movie alot more. Given, it does follow the script of the movie closely and Joker's character wasn't written very well in this book but the book is certainly not poorly written and unimpressive to say the least. I've seen worser adaptations (See Craig Shaw Gardner's "Batman" for that, it's almost scene for scene-word for word of the movie). People have to realize that novelizations of movies are pretty much going to follow things from the movie. A good writer will give us a little extra, as Denny has in this book.
If you hadn't seen the movie and love to read, I suggest reading the book. But, make for sure you see the movie when it comes out...it's not to be missed!!
Rating:  -
I read lots of movie novelizations. Now, books based on movies are never going to be award winners or be on any New York Times best list. But I still enjoy them. This book, however, was pretty poor.
Novelizations offer the one thing movies can't, what the characters are thinking. This book doesn't. It's just the dialogue and action. It seemed like I was reading sections faster than they happened on screen. It had everything the film did, but without the great performances or any internal dialogue it was plain uninteresting. This read more like a screenplay than a book.
Skip this book. See the movie. If you've seen it, see it again. If you're in the mood for a good book based on a successful movie read Incredible Hulk or Iron Man. The movie was fantastic, this book definitely was not.
Rating: -
The sad truth about novelizations is that they start out handicapped. Usually the writer is working from the script rather than the finished film. You can't get the book published close enough to the film's release date otherwise.
That explains both the rushed copy-editing (for example, "He looked first at the *prisoner's* ferry, *laying* maybe a hundred yards off the port bow..." -- note the singular possessive and the incorrect verb) and the obvious 'factual' errors (for example, the ferry radios work and the captains contact each other, which was wisely cut from the film version to heighten tension and remove a plot hole) in Dennis O'Neil's adaptation of "The Dark Knight." It also helps explain the stripped feel to the narrative. Because O'Neil didn't know how the actors would perform their lines, he presents dialogue with hardly any attempt to convey its sound or pacing, and because he didn't know what the costumes, sets, blocking, and special effects would look like, he skimps on describing both appearances and action scenes.
Unfortunately, a book written that way is like a stool with only two and a half legs; it wobbles something awful. For me, Dennis O'Neil's version of "The Dark Knight" feels like a comic script before it's turned over the the artist. Half of the story is, therefore, missing. This is understandable -- O'Neil wrote comics long before he ventured into novels -- but I find it sad that he didn't stretch to master a new form.
On the good side, O'Neil provides backstory for Harvey Dent, explaining why he's so desperate for the world to make sense and be fair. He also makes explicit some of the film's subtext on terrorism, torture, and the ethical lines Bruce is sliding over. But the backstory elements front-weight the book, leaving nowhere near enough page time to convey the full impact of the main plot, and especially shortchanging the climax and denouement.
Overall, "The Dark Knight" is a tolerable way to kill a few hours, but I wouldn't advise buying it.
Rating: -
Dennis O'Neil really knows his Dark Knight and this novelization of the movie adds substance even if you've seen the movie. You discover what happened to the Scarecrow in between the two movies and other bits that extends the movie's storyline. O'Neil captures the internal thoughts of Bruce Wayne/Batman, something that a movie can't quite do. Well done for a "novelization."
Rating: -
When I had bought the book, Iwas expecting to be as well written as O'Neil's adaptation of Batman Begins and Batman: Knightfall, but was sadly disappointed. The novel is very bland and almost seems rushed. This is a serious decline in quality in O'neil's work. Here's hoping he is able to redeem himself. Still, the book gives a liitle more backround on characters from the film, specifically Harvey Dent and adds in some extra scenes that were most likely cut from the final version of the film.
Still, the book is decent enough, and any Batfan should pick it up just to have it in their Batcollection or for those who want a little more backround on events from the film..
PARTY ON, DUDES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Television Show
Collectibles
Movie Searches
|
|
|
Search for posters,
art prints, photos, collectables, merchandise, toys, t-shirts
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Join the Nielsen//NetRatings Research Panel and you could win a new car, a dream vacation, a dream home makeover or $50,000 Cash!
TV Guide
Program listings, celebrity profiles, industry
gossip, movie reviews, puzzle.
More
Entertainment
& TV Magazines
This site is
Hosted
by Bluehost
Read
my Bluehost Review
Original Superhero & other designs for t-shirts, bumper
stickers, prints, mugs, and other cool merchandise. |
|
